Which Is Better: First Alert Or Kidde? A Tale Of Two Alarms

Having a reliable smoke and carbon monoxide monitor is important if you want to keep your home and family safe from fire and carbon monoxide.

First Alert and Kidde are two of the most well-known names on the market. Which one is better, though?

In this piece, we’ll take a closer look at the features, technology, and customer feedback of both brands to help you make an informed choice.

Which is Better: First Alert or Kidde?

As far as its alarm system with a verbal warning of threat is concerned, First Alert appears to be superior to Kidde. The ability to provide a clear and audible message can assist individuals in identifying the specific threat and taking prompt and appropriate action. In emergency situations, this feature provides a significant level of security for households and businesses.

What to think about when picking out a smoke and CO detector?

You already know that these devices are important for keeping you and your family safe from fire and carbon monoxide. So, let’s get started and talk about the things you need to think about when you buy.

Types of Detectors

There are two main types of smoke and CO detectors: those that use ionization and those that use photoelectric sensors. Ionization detectors are better at picking up on fires that burn quickly, while photoelectric detectors are better at picking up on fires that burn slowly. Many later models offer both kinds of protection to make them even safer.

Power Source

Carbon monoxide and smoke alarms can run on batteries, be hardwired into your home’s electrical system, or both. Battery-powered devices are easier to move around and set up, but the batteries need to be replaced often. Hardwired devices are more reliable and can be connected to each other to make the system even safer.

Features and Technology

Modern smoke and carbon monoxide alarms come with a variety of features and technologies, such as voice alerts, smartphone integration, and the ability to work with smart homes. The price of the device may go up because of these features, but they make it easier to use and safer.

Price and Value for Money

Depending on the features and technology they have, smoke and CO alarms can cost anywhere from less than $20 to more than $100. Even though it may be tempting to choose the cheapest choice, it’s important to think about how much money you’ll save in the long run. Less expensive devices might need new batteries more often or might not last as long as more expensive ones.

First Alert vs Kidde: Brand Comparison

Both brands are well-known and reputable, but which one is the better choice for you? Let’s dive into a side-by-side comparison to find out.

FeaturesFirst AlertKidde
Smart Home CompatibilityYesNo
Voice AlertsYesYes
Carbon Monoxide DetectionYesYes
Dual Sensor Smoke DetectionYesYes
Battery BackupYesYes
Warranty10 years5-10 years
Price Range$15 – $150$10 – $100

First Alert and Kidde smoke and carbon monoxide alarms offer a range of features and technological advances, as you can see. First Alert offers an extended warranty and is compatible with other smart home devices, while Kidde offers more affordable options.

In both models, voice alerts, carbon monoxide detection, and dual-sensor smoke detection are standard features. As an extra layer of protection against blackouts, both manufacturers also offer battery backups.

Kidde has the edge when it comes to price range, with some of its products starting at just $10. First Alert can cost you as much as $150 for some of their devices.

To make things easier for you, I’ve put together a table of the pros and cons of each brand. Let’s dive in and see which one comes out on top.

First Alert ProsFirst Alert ConsKidde ProsKidde Cons
Advanced technology, such as mobile app connectivity and remote monitoringCan be on the pricier sideMore affordable optionsLimited advanced features
Wide range of options, from basic smoke detectors to advanced smart systemsRequires more frequent testing than KiddeUser-friendly designLimited smart home integration
Excellent customer support, with 24/7 hotlines and online resourcesSome users have reported false alarmsEasy-to-install optionsMay not be as durable as First Alert
Long-lasting batteries and regular testing remindersSome users have reported issues with compatibilitySnap-on mounting bracket for easy installationLimited options for advanced systems
Some models come with carbon monoxide detectors includedNot all models are compatible with smart home devicesExcellent reputation for reliabilityMay not be as customizable as First Alert

It comes down to your budget and specific needs to decide whether First Alert or Kidde is the better choice. First Alert has the edge in terms of technology and has a variety of options, while Kidde is the more affordable and convenient option.

Things to think about when deciding between First Alert and Kidde


Price is always the most important thing to think about when buying something. Home protection systems are the same way. Both First Alert and Kidde have a variety of choices, from simple smoke detectors to smart systems with a lot of features. But Kidde usually has cheaper choices than First Alert, which tends to be on the more expensive side.


Both names have their own strengths when it comes to features. First Alert is known for having advanced technology, like the ability to connect to a mobile app and send messages to your phone. On the other hand, Kidde is known for its simple, easy-to-use style.


The ease of installation is another important thing to think about. No one wants to spend hours putting together a system that is hard to use. Both First Alert and Kidde have choices that are easy to set up, but Kidde’s snap-on mounting bracket is the easiest to use.


It is very important to keep up with home security systems. You want a method that is easy to keep up and doesn’t need to be watched over all the time. Both First Alert and Kidde have batteries that last a long time and tell you to test them regularly. But First Alert needs to be checked more often than Kidde.

Customer service is the last important thing to think about when picking a home security system. You want a brand that you can trust and that will help you if something goes wrong. Both First Alert and Kidde have great customer service, with hotlines that are open 24/7 and online tools that are easy to use.

Which brand’s technology is better?

How about we start with First Alert? People know these guys for their high-tech gadgets that can find almost anything that could go wrong in your home. We’re talking about ionization, photoelectric, and electrochemical monitors. How much more high-tech can you get?

I won’t even talk about how they connect to Wi-Fi. You can now have your smoke alarm tell you right on your phone when your toast is burnt. Technology is great, isn’t it?

Kidde is next. These guys also have dual-sensor technology, which is nice, but they don’t have First Alert’s sweet, sweet electrochemical sensor. It’s like the difference between a normal flashlight and one of those fancy headlamps that hikers wear.

But don’t worry, fans of Kidde: you can still connect your alarms to a home security system or smart home hub. And, hey, you even get the bonus of being able to use Alexa. Who needs Google Assistant or Siri? Am I right?

Both businesses have what you need when it comes to voice alerts. But let’s be honest, who wouldn’t want to record their own personal message for their smoke detector? “Hey, buddy, stop smoking in the house or I’ll start screaming again.” Classic.

And finally, we have merging of smart homes. Again, First Alert wins the prize because it works with both Apple HomeKit and Amazon Alexa. I mean, come on, with that kind of integration, even your smoke alarm is cooler than you.

Types of Sensors

Both First Alert and Kidde alarms have dual-sensor technology, which uses both ionization and photoelectric sensors to find more smoke. But First Alert also has a third kind of monitor called an electrochemical sensor that is made to find carbon monoxide.

Wireless Connectivity

Both brands have ways to connect their devices wirelessly, so you can link them to a home security system or smart home hub. Kidde, on the other hand, only has radio frequency (RF) connectivity. First Alert, on the other hand, also has Wi-Fi connectivity.

Voice Alerts

Both First Alert and Kidde devices have voice alerts, which can be especially helpful for people who have trouble hearing or who are in places with a lot of noise. But First Alert is better because it lets you customize voice alerts and record your own voice message in addition to the usual pre-recorded messages.

Integration with Smart Home Devices

Both brands can connect to smart home devices, so you can use a smartphone app or a smart home assistant to handle your detectors with your voice. But First Alert is better because it works with both Apple HomeKit and Amazon Alexa. Kidde, on the other hand, only works with Amazon Alexa.


What is the lifespan of a smoke and carbon monoxide detector?

Most detectors last about 10 years, but some may last longer or shorter based on how they are used and cared for.

How often should I replace my detector’s batteries?

It’s best to change the batteries every six months, but some types have batteries that last longer or are hardwired into your home’s electricity.

Can I test my detector’s sensors myself?

Yes, most devices have a “test” button that lets you see if the sensors are working right.

Do I need a separate detector for smoke and carbon monoxide?

No, there are many types of detectors that can detect both smoke and carbon monoxide. This can save you money and room.

How do I install and maintain my detector?

Each model has different directions for how to set up and maintain it, but most detectors are easy to set up with screws or glue. To make sure your device is working well, you should test it often and clean it.

Which brand is better in the end?

After comparing First Alert and Kidde, it’s clear that both make high-quality smoke and carbon monoxide alarms with a variety of features and technologies. In the end, the best name for you will depend on what you need and what you like.

First Alert is the better choice if you’re looking for a monitor that works with smart home devices. They also have a bigger selection of goods and have won a lot of awards and praise.

But if you want to save money or want a simpler model, Kidde might be a better pick. Their devices are often cheaper, and customers have said good things about them.

Overall, both First Alert and Kidde are well-known brands that have won their place on the market. With the right device, you can rest easy knowing that you and your family are safe from fire and carbon monoxide.

Read more: